Transcript of Technology Chat with Dean Larry Fried and Colleagues
Wed., Aug. 1, 2007
[ See full list of transcripts and chats ]
DeanSree(P) Good afternoon, everyone. We are excited to see all of you
soon. The M.S. Broadcast and New Media majors arrive Monday, Aug. 6, the
M.S. Print folks arrive Thursday, Aug. 16 and the M.A. students arrive
Thursday, Aug. 30.
DeanSree(P) Now it’s my pleasure to introduce Larry Fried, asst. dean
for technology. He has been with us for a year now and has helped
upgrade our technology and technology services in many exciting ways. Over to
Dean Fried.
DeanFried(P) Good afternoon, and welcome to the J School Technology
chat. I have with me Alan Elmore, IT Manager, and Craig Hettich, Broadcast
Technology Manager. We’ll be taking your questions.
DeanSree(P) Please be patient as they answer your questions - and
keep sending in new ones.
lam_vo(Q) How much technical equipment (apart from using the lab for
the software) would be probably need for new media projects?
CHettich(A) The Equipment Room has 3 types of equipment NM students
will use.
Audio=Portable Flash recorders
Video=Sony A1U HDV Camcorders
Photo=Canon Still Cameras.
jlm2176(Q) Do print students do most of their interviews on tape
recorder and if so, what do you recommend.
DeanFried(A) There are several recording devices that we recommend
-if you have an iPod, look into the XtremeMac Digital Voice recorder.
Dara(Q) Is a recording device necessary for print folks?
DeanFried(A) It is not required that you purchase a recording device.
Our Equipment room will lend out recorders for assignments requiring
audio.
mathildep(Q) Hi there, I have a non-digital Nikon SLR. I’ve been
thinking of making the switch to digital when I realised prices have
become much more affordable (ish), especially if I just get the camera
box and keep the lenses I already have (AF 28-105 - and yes I know the D-40
isn’t compatible). However, everyone (or almost) says Canon digital SLRs
are better, and that getting a package deal camera+lens isn’t much more
expensive than camera alone. What’s your advice on this?
CHettich(A) You’ll have to weigh the cost of a new camera and lens VS
the value of retaining your lens and finding the camera and/or adapter
that work with the lens. Keep in mind that most 35MM film lenses are not
the same focal length in the Digital World as the sensor is not the same
size as the film plane.
mathildep(Q) Related to this, is it worth it getting a phone with an
integrated camera, just in case we witness something? Or should we just
carry around our real camera at all times for that? If the former,
what’s
the minimum useful megapixels we should aim for?
CHettich(A) Capturing the right composition is more important than
detail of the photo. That said, below about 4 Mega Pixels most images
lose
a lot of detail, especially in low light.
Dara(Q) Do you recommend using a recorder for assignments that do not
require audio? Or just the old pen and notepad system?
DeanFried(A) While a recorder is preferable, we do not have enough
equipment to lend out to cover all assignments. So, pen & paper is
sufficient if you prefer not to buy your own equipment.
Dara(Q) This is for Alan: I have a Dell PC at home, but I’m going to
buy
a MacBook. I’m a print concentrator, so I’m going to be generating a lot
of text documents. what do I need to do to be able to move them from the
Apple to the PC and vice versa, and work on them on both computers? Or
is
this even possible? (I’m a neophyte at this stuff–email, word, and a
little photoshop are the only skills I have!)
AElmore(A) You will find that we are a mixed PC and Mac environment
here
at the Journailsm School. We have Office 2003 for Windows and Microsoft
Office 2004 for Mac on all our student PC’s and Macs. You can easily
work
on text documents and share them between environments. For your own
machine, I would recommend having the appropriate Office product
installed.
Sydney(Q) I accidentally clicked out of the chat room for a moment,
if
you answered my question about laptops, would you please repost it?
DeanFried(A) Sydney, can you please repeat your laptop question?
Sydney(Q) I am a broadcast concentrator with a pretty decent laptop
PC.
Before I consider upgrading to something new, what is your sense of the
amount of computer intense (i.e. requiring fancier computer standards)
activities that a student would do on her own computer, rather than the
university’s?
CHettich(A) Lab computers are not always available because of
classes,
but we have not had complaints from broadcast students about a lack of
computer access. It’s nice to have a laptop for email, web and text
documents.
Dara(Q) Can I take advantage of the Apple Store discount if I don’t
have
a student ID yet?
DeanFried(A) All you need is a UNI to get the Apple Store discounts.
Remember to look at both the University and J School Apple discount
pages
to determine the best deal for you.
mathildep(Q) Craig Hettich, stuff focal length not being the same a
little to technical for me - is this the problem I’ve been told Nikon
has,
more than Canon? How can it be avoided, by buying lenses made for
digital?
CHettich(A) All it means is a 35MM lens (made for a film camera) on a
Digital SLR is different than on film SLR in what you see through the
viewfinder. Just make sure your lens is compatible with the camera you
buy, meaning it will attach itself with or without an adapter.
anupk(Q) Is there a separate url for apple store discounts for us?
DeanFried(A) J School URL: http://web.jrn.columbia.edu/jrnapplestore
Columbia URL: http://www.columbia.edu/AcIS/sales
Sydney(Q) I already have a laptop with 1GB of ram and some other
decent
specs. I’m hoping I don’t have to upgrade and it sounds like I might not
have to. Thanks.
AElmore(A) For basic word processing and image processing, that is
certainly sufficient. However, if you need to run specialty software
then
make sure to read the minimum manufacturer requirements for your
platform.
Sydney(Q) I have a 3.2 megapixel Canon digital camera which I love
(it’s
so compact). The tech memo recommended cameras with more than 4
megapixel.
Do you have any recommendations for similarly compact cameras like the
elph?
CHettich(A) Look at online user feedback. It all depends on your
intended use. Do you want control or do you just want to point and
shoot.
Sydney(Q) Also, what kind of zoom?
CHettich(A) Avoid using a digital zoom.
Sydney(Q) About the laptop, what sort of specialty software would I
be
using?
DeanFried(A) You don’t need to purchase any special software, other
than
MS Office. All other software is accessible in our labs.
Dara(Q) Here’s a laptop question: Do most people take their laptops
out
on their beats? If not, is there a safe place to keep it at the
J-School?
(How big are those lockers, anyway?)
AElmore(A) Dean Sree probably knows better than I if most students
bring
them out. However, if you have a wireless card and wireless account,
wireless access is everywhere. I imagine you could easily do your work
out
in the field - however, unless you are within the Journailsm School and
on one of our computers, you will not have access to your student file
shares.
And yes, the lockers are big enough to store a laptop - however, the
safest place for your laptop is to keep it with you at all times!
mathildep(Q) I haven’t seen my question about email capable phones
answered, should I ask it again or was it not relevant for this chat?
DeanFried(A) A smartphone is nice to have but very pricy - not
necessary
for the J School environment.
Sydney(Q) Thanks. And as a follow up, would I then be installing that
software on my own laptop, or just using it at the labs?
DeanFried(A) You access the software on lab computers.
ldh2113(Q) What laptop do you suggest I buy?
DeanFried(A) For most students any Mac or Windows laptop with
wireless
capability will suffice. For broadcast concentrators, go with a MacBook
Pro.
Sydney(Q) Okay, thanks, so just to clarify, I don’t need for my
personal
laptop to have the specs for the specialty software at the labs?
DeanFried(A) Correct. One other thing that would be very useful is an
external hard drive - we recommend the Lacie rugged triple interface
drives. Special J School discount available on these available at B&H
Photovideo.
Dara(Q) By the way, I checked both the J-school and the Columbia
links
to the Apple store, and the prices on Apple products are the same.
DeanFried(A) Prices for most products are the same, but there are
special promotions that are sometimes available on one site and not the
other, so always check both before you buy.
Dara(Q) Apple experts, can I get Palm software for a MacBook? I’m
rather
Treo-addicted!
CHettich(A) It exists. You can always run Palm in the Windows
environment on the Mac too.
Graciela_Ibanez(Q) how much are the university or school discounts?
DeanFried(A) On certain models, the J School page offers discounts of
approx. $50-$100 lower than the University. I know that the University
had
a promotion going to get a free iPod Nano when you buy a Macbook - don’t
think that’s available on the J School site.
Sydney(Q) One more follow up to the last two questions/answers–if I
have a PC as a broadcast concentrator, will I end up hating life?
DeanFried(A) Definitely not! The MacBook suggestion is for those who
are
looking to purchase a new laptop. All software that you need is
available
in our labs, so you’ll do fine with what you have.
gayle(Q) hi, will broadcast students be ok with a Dell at least
initially
CHettich(A) Yes. I encourage students not to buy their own editing
software until after they graduate. Use what we have and decide what
works
best for you. We have 35 Avids in labs and and edit rooms. There is
usuaully one available.
Dara(Q) Yeah, free nano is available on the J-school site, too.
DeanFried(A) It wasn’t supposed to be available here, so it could get
pulled from our site, if that’s of interest to you.
Dara(Q) Aren’t we all going to hate life just a little?
DeanFried(A) Well maybe, but we’ll do our best to keep it to a
minimum!
ys2363(Q) Hi there, thank you for doing this. Can Columbia students
get
any discount when buying a MacBook? If yes, what is the discount,
approximately, and where do they order the Mac from? Thank you!
DeanFried(A) J School URL: http://web.jrn.columbia.edu/jrnapplestore
(available to J School students only)
Columbia URL: http://www.columbia.edu/AcIS/sales
(available to any Columbia student)
Check both sites - prices & promotions change.
mathildep(Q) For broadcast and new media, why should we get a MacBook
Pro when you say that we’ll using lab computers for work requiring
special
software?
CHettich(A) Many students want to run editing software on their
computers. If you need to buy a laptop and plan on eventually running
Avid
or FCP, then we recommend a Macbook Pro. If you already have a laptop
with
a wireless card, then you’ll be fine using the school systems for video
and audio editing. You can then buy what you like best at the end of the
school year and still get an educational discount.
anupk(Q) Dean Fried, I saw you suggested Lacie rugged triple
interface
drives. I own an Iomega 160 GB. Could you please kindly explain if there
is sth. specific I need or the one I have will work fine?
CHettich(A) We suggest a drive that has both USB and Fire Wire
interfaces. Craig
ys2363(Q) Are the labs to be used by new media and broadcast students
open 24 hrs?
DeanFried(A) Labs are open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, and are
available any time that a class is not in session in the room.
ecb2124(Q) Will we each be given any dedicated server space to store
our
work?
AElmore(A) All students have one GigaByte of space on our file
server.
Depending on your concentration, you may have other file server space
for
your video or audio work.
ys2363(Q) And one more question: how can international students buy
and
use a cell phone here? I tried a couple of Verizon and T-Mobile stores
here in Manhattan last night and I was told that since i don’t have
credit
history in this country, i am basically not eligible to use the phone
companies’ plans. I have a social security number, but that, they said,
doesn’t quite help since i lack credit history. Thank you!
DeanFried(A) That’s a tough one … have you tried AT&T?
Sydney(Q) Great! Thanks for your help on that line of questioning.
About
the external hard drive, I have a nice big stationary one (Maxtor). Do
students use portable ones a lot, or would a stationary one in my
apartment be sufficient?
CHettich(A) I’m guessing what you mean by stationary is that it
weighs
more than a bottle of water and requires a bulky AC power supply. If you
are comfortable carrying that around the school then, you’ll be fine
with
it. They aren’t usually as durable as the portable AC power-free models.
anupk(Q) For ys2363 - from my experience (I am an int’l student too),
I
put down a small amount as a deposit and I got my phone from T-mobile. I
am pretty sure if you are willing to put down a deposit, they will
qualify
you.
DeanFried(A) Thanks!
Sydney(Q) I hope to just leave it at my apartment. Do students need
them
during the day too?
CHettich(A) If you plan on using it to either transfer work or backup
work done at the school, then yes, you’ll need to bring it to school.
Sydney(Q) I see. Thanks. How do we get the J-School discount from
B&H?
DeanFried(A) You have to use the special codes provided in the
technology letter sent out a few weeks ago. If you no longer have the
codes, email me at lfried@columbia.edu and I’ll send them to you.
DeanSree(P) Ok, folks, i will open this up in a minute… talk
amongst
yourselves…
Dara(Q) Radio question: Is the sound quality from the XtreamMac ipod mic
good enough for radio reports? For both sound bites and ambient sound?
How does it compare to, say, a dictaphone microrecorder?
CHettich(A) Good question. I have never used the XremeMac Mic and
would not for any Broadcast audio recording. We have many HiMD Sony Recorders
just for Radio classes. They come with an RE50 Mic that we feel provides
very good sound quality. For a soundbyte posted on a website, I’m sure an XtremeMac Mic is fine.
DeanFried(P) Ok, thanks to all of you for participating and for your
great questions. We’ll see you at Orientation.
[ends]